Jillian Alyssa

Just ate here tonight with my fiancé and I just have to say we had the BEST experience. The food is absolutely delicious and the service is outstanding. There is no exaggeration here. My fiancé left his liners on the table, and on our way home we called the restaurant (and they had already closed) and they said they knew and put them aside for him sealed in a paper bag with our receipt on it so we would know it was his! We love City Island Seafood Shack and can’t wait to come back. It’s definitely going to be one of our regular spots now! 🙂 Thank you for such yummy seafood and the best experience!